Beograd · 43°49′NBeograd— Editorial —‹No. 250Ponedeljak / 16·11·202616·11·26
MODUS
Gastronomy · Editorial

Kitchen knives: steel before price

A 3,000 dinar knife that keeps its edge is better than a 15,000 dinar knife that is lost on the first sharpening stone.

An array of kitchen knives displayed on a shelf
↳ Photo: EMANUELE Ricciardi / Unsplash

A chef who has spent a decade behind the board doesn't measure a knife by the brand on the handle, but by how long it holds the edge before it has to return to the stone. That's the difference between a knife that's worth the money and one that's just a nicely packaged piece of metal.

Steel hardness is a number, not a feeling

Every serious knife has a hardness expressed inHRC(Rockwell C scale). Soft kitchen knives from the supermarket run around 52-54 HRC — they sharpen easily, but the edge bends after cutting a dozen tomatoes. A good European knife (Wüsthof, Zwilling type) is kept in the 56-58 HRC range: a compromise between sharpness and ease of maintenance. Japanese knives made from VG-10 or high carbon steel go as high as 60-62 HRC — they hold a razor longer, but are more brittle and will break if dropped on tile or cut into bone.

The rule is simple: the higher the HRC, the longer it holds the edge, but the harder it is to sharpen and the easier it is for the edge to break on a side impact. An everyday knife seeks the middle, not the extreme.

Steel typeHardness (HRC)An advantageMana
Stainless, soft (supermarket)52-54Easy to sharpen, cheapIt's losing its edge fast
German/European (X50CrMoV15)56-58Impact resistant, durableAsk for sharpening for 2-3 weeks
Japanese VG-10 / AUS-1060-61Keeps sharp longer, precise cutBrittle, not for cutting bone
carbon steel58-64It sharpens the fastest, the sharpest edgeIt will rust if it stays wet

Three knives are enough, not twelve in a block

Twelve-piece kitchen sets are marketing, not tools. A professional kitchen relies on three knives.Chef's knife(chef's knife) of 20 centimeters does 80 percent of the work — chopping, mincing, filleting soft meat.A paring knife(paring knife) of 8-9 centimeters takes on small jobs where a chef's knife does not stop — cleaning fruit, removing seeds. It's the thirdserrated bread knife, because the smooth blade crushes the bark instead of cutting it — a 20-25 centimeter saw with deep teeth cuts through the bark without pressure.

Everything else—fillet knives, santoku, cheese knives—comes only when these three wear out from use, not before.

Maintenance decides more than purchase

A knife that is "corrected" on a daily basisflies(honing steel, not sharpened, just a flat edge that bends microscopically from use) keeps its sharpness for months longer than a knife that is never touched after purchase. Real sharpening on the stone is done only when the fly is no longer helpful — with daily use, this is approximately every three to six weeks, depending on the surface on which it is being cut.

A wooden and plastic cutting board preserves the edge; the glass and stone board destroy it in a few strokes, no matter how good the knife. It's a detail that hardly anyone associates with a loss of sharpness — blame the knife, and blame the pad.

Balance and handle, not just the blade

The knife is tested in the hand, not on a spec sheet. The balance point of a good chef's knife is roughly where the blade meets the handle — the knife "pulling" forward toward the tip tires the hand after half an hour of chopping. Full tang construction, where the metal goes through the entire handle, gives better balance and durability than a knife where the blade is just glued into the plastic handle.

Forged vs. Stamped — the difference you can feel in your hand

Forged knife(forged) is made from a single piece of heated steel that is hammered into shape under a press — a process that compacts the structure of the metal and produces a thicker, heavier blade with a natural transition to a bolster (a thickening between the blade and the handle that protects the fingers).Stamped knife(stamped) is cut from a sheet of steel plate like cookies from the dough, then it is subsequently ground and sharpened. The result is a thinner, lighter blade with no bolster.

Soft kitchen knives from the supermarket run around 52-54 HRC — they sharpen easily, but the edge bends after cutting a dozen tomatoes.

The difference in price is significant, but the difference in performance is less than the marketing claims: a good stamped knife made of quality steel, well sharpened, cuts almost as well as a forged one. What a forged knife really offers is better balance due to the mass in the bolster and greater resistance to bending the blade under higher pressure — important for a professional kitchen where the knife is used hundreds of times a day, less important for a household that cooks once a day.

Why do Japanese and European knives have a different shape

The European chef's knife has a rounded blade that allows for the "rock chop" technique — the knife swings back and forth while the tip remains on the board, useful for quickly chopping herbs and onions. JapaneseSantokuorgyutothe knife has a straighter blade line and is made with a forward-and-down motion, a "push cut" technique, which gives a more precise, thinner cut — better for cutting fish or vegetables where a clean cut is desired without crushing the cells.

This difference in geometry is not stylistic but functional: Japanese cuisine historically calls for thin, precise cuts (sashimi, thinly sliced ​​vegetables for quick frying), while European cuisine calls for the speed of processing large quantities of ingredients at once. A chef who learns both techniques has a wider repertoire, but for a beginner a good European-style chef's knife still covers most everyday situations.

What do the numbers and letters on the blade mean

Markings such as VG-10, AUS-8 or 1095 on the blade are not marketing jargon but steel alloy designations, each carrying a specific composition. VG-10, a Japanese stainless steel, contains about 1 percent carbon and an addition of cobalt that improves sharpness retention. AUS-8 is a cheaper, softer alternative (58-59 HRC) that is easier to sharpen but loses its edge more quickly. The 1095 designation indicates chrome-free carbon steel — it sharpens the fastest, cuts the most aggressively, but rusts if not wiped clean immediately after use and not allowed to sit wet for an hour.

Damascus steel (damascus), recognizable by the wavy pattern on the blade, is not a special alloy, but a technique of stacking several layers of different steel that are riveted together — the pattern is aesthetic, while the quality of the cut depends on the core of the steel in the middle, which carries the real sharpness. A knife with a nice damascus pattern and a bad core will cut worse than an ordinary single layer knife with good steel — the beauty of the blade and the sharpness are two completely separate promises that the buyer must check separately, not assume that one automatically brings the other.

Hidden Gems: details the seller won't tell himself

The sharpening angle changes everything, and it is rarely written on the box: European knives are traditionally sharpened at 20-22 degrees to the side, Japanese at 15-17 — that's why the Japanese knife seems "sharper" out of the box, but that thinner edge is less prone to lateral bending. A 3,000 dinar knife with 56 HRC steel, regularly sharpened with a flywheel, holds its edge longer than a 15,000 dinar knife that was thrown into the fork drawer after the first use — the price on the box does not guarantee anything if the knife is not touched with a sharpening stone after purchase. And perhaps the most important detail: a dishwasher-safe knife loses its sharpness faster than any other factor on this list, as vibration and collision with other utensils microscopically warps the edge from wash to wash.

Who arranges the rest of the kitchen with a good knife,text about pansfollows the same logic — steel and hardness before the brand on the handle or bottom of the pan. A paring knife with a thin, precise blade is particularly noticeableAjvar seasonwhich just begins, when the pepper is peeled in kilograms, not in a few pieces for the salad.

Questions & answers

short and to the point
What are the best kitchen knives for everyday use?
Three knives cover almost all the work: a 20 cm chef's knife with a hardness of 56-58 HRC, an 8-9 cm paring knife and a serrated bread knife.
Why are knives not dishwasher safe?
Vibration and collision with other accessories in the machine microscopically bends the blade and accelerates the loss of sharpness more than any other habit.
How often should a kitchen knife be sharpened?
A fly is used before each major use to smooth the edge, and proper sharpening on the stone should be done for 4 to 6 weeks in daily cooking.

Read on

from the same press