Beograd · 43°49′NBeograd— Editorial —‹No. 250Ponedeljak / 16·11·202616·11·26
MODUS
Enology · Blog

Whiskey as a gift when you don't know what he drinks

A gifted bottle of whiskey usually ends up in the cupboard unopened. It is not the price that is to blame, but the guesswork, which is replaced by one question about coffee.

A glass of whiskey on an old wooden table
↳ Photo: phil cruz / Unsplash

The most expensive gift whiskey mistake is Lagavulin for the man who drinks coffee with three sugar cubes. He will not like the smoke, he will keep the bottle out of decency, and after five years it will still be full to the brim. Whiskey is chosen not by price but by the taste of the person who gets it — and that taste can be checked without asking about the whiskey.

One question instead of guessing

Ask how he drinks his coffee, or see what he eats. It's a crude filter, but it hits more often than it misses:

  • Coffee with milk and sugar, sweets after lunch→ bourbon. The new oak barrel gives vanilla and caramel, and it's the most approachable style.
  • Black coffee without sugar, likes bitter chocolate and strong cheese→ Islay or island Scottish. Smoke, iodine, salt.
  • - You don't know anything.→ Irish or mild Scotch from Speyside. Soft, fruity, without sharp edges.

If you forwhiskey as a giftjust need a name: when you don't know anything about a man, the Redbreast 12 is a bottle that almost no one returns. If the budget is smaller, Monkey Shoulder.

Five bottles in three budgets

BudgetA bottleStyleApproximate price in Serbia
up to 4,500 RSDMonkey Shoulderscotch blended malt, honey and vanilla3,500-4,200 dinars
up to 4,500 RSDBuffalo Tracebourbon, caramel and orange3,800-4,500 dinars
RSD 4,500-10,000Talisker 10island single malt, pepper and smoke6,000-7,000 dinars
RSD 4,500-10,000Redbreast 12irish single pot still, dried fruit and spice7,500-9,000 dinars
over RSD 10,000Lagavulin 16Islay single malt, smoke and iodine11,000-13,000 dinars

Monkey Shoulderis a blended malt, a mixture of single malts from Speyside without grain alcohol. It is drunk neat, with ice and in a cocktail, so it makes a good gift for someone just starting out.Buffalo Traceis a Kentucky corn-based bourbon — sweeter, fuller, and the answer for those who normally drink cognac or rum.

Talisker 10from the Isle of Skye is a bridge between mild and smoky: it has smoke but is covered by pepper and sea salt. If you're not sure if the recipient likes smoke, this is a safer bottle than Islay.Redbreast 12is made from a mixture of malted and unmalted barley in a copper cauldron (pot still) and distilled three times. The result is a thick, smooth whiskey with prune and sherry flavors, and it's the safest choice in the whole table.

Lagavulin 16is a gift just for someone you know likes a smoke. It's probably the best bottle in the store for him. For others, it is an expensive ashtray.

If you for whiskey as a gift just need a name: when you don't know anything about a man, the Redbreast 12 is a bottle that almost no one returns.

Prices are approximate for wine shops and larger markets in Belgrade and Novi Sad and change by shares; before the holidays, gift packs with glasses appear, which are usually more expensive per liter.

What else to think about before checkout?

Age on labelindicates the youngest whiskey in the bottle, not the average. A twelve-year-old is not automatically better than an unmarked one, but it is more predictable. For a gift, predictability is a virtue.

Boxit's worth more than you think. Talisker, Redbreast and Lagavulin usually come in a box; Buffalo Trace and Monkey Shoulder often don't, so carry them in a paper wine store bag, not naked.

Don't buy thumbnailsand gift sets with three 50 ml bottles unless the person collects. They are twice as expensive per liter.

If the recipient already has a policy and you want to understand what's on it, read our guide toScotch whiskey regionsSelectionsingle malts up to 6,000 dinarsand the text onbourbon and rye whiskey. A sentence you can take to the store: don't buy whisky that you would like, but one that suits his coffee.

Questions & answers

short and to the point
What whiskey to buy as a gift if I don't know what he likes?
Mild and fruity: Irish Redbreast 12 (RSD 7,500-9,000) or Scottish Monkey Shoulder (RSD 3,500-4,200). Avoid smoked Islay whiskies if you are unsure.
How much does a good whisky cost to give as a gift?
A decent bottle starts around 3,500 dinars (Monkey Shoulder, Buffalo Trace), a serious single malt is 6,000-9,000 dinars, and Lagavulin 16 exceeds 11,000.
Is older whiskey always better?
No. The number of years on the label indicates the youngest whiskey in the bottle. Older is usually more expensive and predictable, but the taste depends on the barrel and the distillery more than the years.

Read on

from the same press