Robotized gearbox: DSG, Selespeed and PowerShift inside
A robotic gearbox is an ordinary manual box that someone has taken away the clutch pedal and given it to the engine, pump, or computer. It breaks down where it was taken.
Opel Corsa with Easytronic gearbox at the traffic lights in Belgrade, in first gear, on a slight incline: the car jerks, the passenger's head nods forward, and the letter N flashes on the dashboard. It's not an engine or gear failure, but a fist-sized electric motor that holds the clutch and after 120,000 kilometers stopped knowing where its zero is.
All the gearboxes from the title have the same: in the box are the gears of the manual gearbox, and instead of your left foot and right hand workactuators. The difference is in how many clutches there are, whether they are dry or in oil, and whether they are driven by electricity or hydraulics. It also depends on what is broken and how much it costs.
How a semi-automatic transmission works
In Short:semi-automatic or robotic gearboxis a manual gearbox where the computer decides when the clutch is opened and what speed is inserted, and this is physically performed by electric motors or hydraulic cylinders. In a single clutch transmission (AMT), traction is interrupted during the change, as when the driver manually changes. In a gearbox withtwo clutches(DSG, PowerShift) the next gear is already inserted on the second shaft, so it just switches from one clutch to the other, without interruption.
| Gearbox | Where it was installed | Clutch | Drive | The most common failure |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Selespeed (Magneti Marelli) | Alfa Romeo 156, 147, GT | single, dry | electrohydraulics: pump, pressure accumulator, valves | pump, pressure accumulator, position sensors |
| Dualogic | Fiat Punto, Grande Punto, 500, Panda | one, dry | electrohydraulics, same family as Selespeed | pump and hydraulic leakage |
| Easytronic | Opel Corsa C and D, Meriva A, Astra H, Zafira B | single, dry | electric motors | clutch actuator, motor brushes, adaptation |
| DSG DQ200 | VW, Skoda, seat, Audi up to 250 Nm | two, dry, 7 speed | mechatronics with hydraulics | mechatronics, clutch jerking when starting |
| DSG DQ250 | stronger VW and Audi up to 350 Nm | two, in oil, 6 speed | mechatronics | mechatronics when oil change is skipped |
| PowerShift DPS6 | Ford Focus III, Fiesta, since 2011 | two, dry, 6 speed | electric motors and control unit | jerk, seals, transmission controller |
| PowerShift MPS6 | Ford Mondeo, S-Max, C-Max, Focus diesel | two, in oil, 6 speed | hydraulics | durable with regular oil |
With a dual-clutch transmission, the trick is to have two input shafts, one inside the other. In the DQ200, the outer, hollow shaft carries the even gears and reverse, and the inner odd; other transmissions arrange reverse differently, but each shaft has its own clutch. While driving in third, the computer has already entered fourth on the second shaft and is waiting; the change is just simultaneously releasing one and tightening the other clutch. When the computer makes a mistake and prepares the fifth, and you suddenly squeeze the gas to overtake, there is a short pause until it switches to the second. That pause is what drivers describe as the "thinking" of the DSG. Transmissions with one clutch have nothing to prepare in advance, so they do each change in order: open the clutch, exit the gear, enter the new one, close the clutch. That is why they are slower, but also simpler and cheaper to repair.
Why dry clutch suffers in the city
This is the most important division for the customer.Dry clutch, like the DQ200 and DPS6, is air-cooled and heated every time the car crawls in a column with the clutch half-open. On the highway, it is an ideal gearbox: light, fast, economical. In the column on the Gazelle, where you start and stop every ten meters, every start is a little slip, and the slip is heat and wear. This is where the familiar comes into beingtrembling on departure, which the owners describe as driving over cobblestones on flat asphalt.
Clutch in oil, like the DQ250 and MPS6, dissipates heat through the oil, handles more torque and city driving. The price is regular oil and filter changes, with a DSG with a wet clutch every time60,000 kilometers. Skipped replacement is the most common cause of expensive mechatronics, and new mechatronics costs more than a thousand euros before installation.
Robotic single clutch gearboxes (Selespeed, Dualogic, Easytronic) have another flaw:interruption of tractionfrom half a second to a second at each change. He who drives with the throttle to the floor feels the wobble. Whoever loosens the throttle a little at the moment of change, as if holding the clutch himself, gets a smooth ride and a longer clutch life. This habit is free and the best that can be done for these gearboxes. As these systems stand next to the classic automatic with inverter and CVT, we have compared in the textAutomatic transmission: four machines under the same letter D, and what does the manual box that is at the base of all of them look like, in the textManual gearbox inside.
All the gearboxes from the title have the same: in the box are the gears of the manual gearbox, and instead of your left foot and right hand work actuators .
What really breaks down and how much it costs
CodeSelespeed and Dualogicthe weak point is hydraulics: the electric pump that maintains the pressure, the pressure accumulator that stores it, and the valves. When the battery loses its throttle, the pump runs more often and longer, a hum is heard after the engine shuts down, and finally the transmission refuses to put in the speed. The battery pump is changed as an assembly, and specialized workshops also offer reparation. We wrote about Selespeed from the point of view of the owner of Alpha 156 in the textAlfa Romeo 156 without nostalgia.
Easytronicthere is no hydraulics, so there is no leakage. It has a clutch actuator with an electric motor whose brushes and position sensor wear out. After replacing the clutch or actuator, the gearbox must passadaptationdiagnostics, otherwise he starts out rough and chooses N when it is not clear where the clutch is. A lot of Easytronic's “malfunctions” disappear after a ten-minute adaptation.
DQ200QUERY LENGTH LIMIT EXCEEDED. MAX ALLOWED QUERY : 500 CHARS
PowerShift DPS6in the Ford Focus III and Fiesta it carries the same dry clutch disease, with leaking input shaft seals that grease the clutch and a gearbox controller that loses connection. WetMPS6in Mondeo and S-Max there is a second gearbox, which withstands up to about 450 Nm and which rarely causes problems with oil on time. When buying a Ford, first check which of the two is installed; the name is the same, the machine is not.
Checks that the seller will not suggest
- Test under a hill.With dry DSG and DPS6, drive three times in a row along a slight slope, in reverse and forward. Trembling cannot be hidden there.
- After 20 minutesA warm gearbox reveals what a cold one hides. A test drive shorter than that is half a test.
- Buzzing after extinguishing.With Selespeed and Dualogic, a pump that turns on several times while the car is turned off means that the accumulator is not holding pressure.
- Diagnostic figures.Clutch wear values and history of adaptations are read on the DSG. If the clutch adaptation has been done several times in a short space of time, the gearbox compensates for the wear and the clutch set is close to the end.
- Braking by motor.The manual mode with plus and minus also works with robotic gearboxes, and on long downhills it preserves the brakes just like with the automatic. We have described how it is used in the textAutomatic downhill.
Final calculation: a used Golf with a dry DQ200 that is cheaper than the same car with a manual gearbox is not a discount, but an advance for a set of clutches. The same car with DSG in oil and oil bills at 60,000 and 120,000 kilometers is a purchase.
Questions & answers
short and to the point- How does a semi-automatic transmission work?
- It is a manual transmission in which the clutch and the gear change are performed by electric motors or hydraulics, at the command of the computer. With one clutch, traction is interrupted when changing, with two clutches, the next gear is already inserted.
- What is the most common malfunction on a DSG gearbox?
- In the seven-speed DQ200 with dry clutches, mechatronics and clutches that tremble on departure. In DSG with clutches in oil, mechatronics, most often when the oil change is skipped to 60,000 km.
- Is Ford PowerShift reliable?
- Depending on the version: the dry DPS6 in the Focus III and Fiesta has been known to flinch and malfunction since 2011. The wet MPS6 in the Mondeo and S-Max withstands about 450 Nm and is durable with regular oil.