Which champagne to buy when the price does not tell the truth
Two bottles, both brut, the difference is nine thousand dinars. More expensive paid for the name; what decides the taste is written in fine print at the bottom of the label.
The seller is waiting and you are looking at two bottles. It says on bothChampagneand it is written on bothBrutus. The price difference is nine thousand dinars and not a single word on the front label explains why. That's the whole problem of buying champagne in one scene: the two pieces of information that the average customer has learned to read are precisely the ones that say nothing.
If you need an answer before the explanation, here it is in three lines.Under four thousand dinarsthere is practically no champagne, so don't waste time: take itcrémant— from Alsace, Burgundy, Loire or Limousin — or homemade sparkling wine made using the classic method, because it is all made by a second fermentation in the bottle, just like the original.Between four and seven thousandmostly there are trade labels with a markM.A— someone else's wine dressed in the name of the chain; you don't know what you are buying there and the price is the only information.Between seven and twelve thousandthere are two different things on the shelf at the same price: the entry-level brut of a big house and a labeled vineyard champagneRMat the bottom of the label. Take another — for the same money, you get wine from one or several neighboring parcels instead of a coupage compiled so as not to deviate from last year.Over fifteen thousandhouses are starting to earn their price, because that's where long-aged and vintage bottles go, which a small cellar can hardly match.
The two letters at the bottom of the label change everything
At the bottom of each bottle of champagne, printed so small that it requires good light, is the code required by law.NM(Négociant-Manipulant) means a house that buys grapes and makes wine — it includes almost everything you know by name.RM(Récoltant-Manipulant) means a winegrower who bottles exclusively his own grapes.CMis a cooperative, aM.Ais someone else's custom-labeled wine, what chains sell under their own brand.
The numbers behind it explain why the difference is so big. The appeal has an eye34,000 hectaresand close16,000 registered winegrowers, and only a few hundred houses. Most of the grapes travel from the plot to someone else's press. The house then assembles a blend from hundreds of plants whose job it is to make it the same every year — it's a top craft, but by definition it's a craft of erasing differences. RM does the opposite: one village, one slope, one visible year. We explained the same mechanism for still wines in the text about ithow white wine is created from harvest to glass; champagne is the same, plus a second fermentation in the bottle.
Not every RM is better than every house. There are winegrowers who make messy wine and houses that maintain a standard that a small cellar cannot. But in the middle range, the ratio of invested and received is on the side of the winegrower, because he does not pay for a campaign that costs more than wine in a bottle.
Names that are worth remembering in that category, because they are searched for by last name and not by brand:Pierre PetersandAgraparton the Côte des Blancs,Larmandier-Bernierin Verti,Egly-Ourietin Ambonea,Chartogne-Tailletin Murphy andWillmartfrom the village of Rilly-la-Montagne. You are looking for the southern part of the appellation, which is also the most favorableCédric Bouchard,Vouette et SorbéeandMarie-Courtin. None of them are rare collector's items, but they are not in chains: they are produced in small quantities and are only available in specialized wine shops.
On the other hand, houses are not all the same product and it is worth knowing whose style is what.BollingerandCirclethey make pinot noir and keep part of the wine in wood, so they are wide and nutty.Taittingerit leans towards Chardonnay and is airier.Charles Heidsieckit keeps the bottles on the lees much longer than the prescribed minimum, and it feels like baked bread in the glass. If you're already paying for a name, at least pay for the style you love.
Range is the only figure that predicts sip
After the second boiling and removal of the sediment, the bottle is topped up with a mixture of wine and sugar. That dose—dosage— is the only thing on the label that reliably announces the taste. Everything else is style; this is the measured value in grams per liter.
| Label | Sugar (g/l) | What a sip |
|---|---|---|
| Brut Nature / Zero | 0-3 | Bone dry, chalk and lemon peel. Merciless to weak wine |
| Extra Brut | 0-6 | Tense and precise; selection with oysters and raw fish |
| Brutus | 0–12 | Standard. Most houses land at 7–9 g/l |
| Extra Dry | 12–17 | It sounds drier than it is. This is where most of the disappointment comes from |
| Sec | 17–32 | Sensibly sweet; with pâté and mature blue cheese |
| Demi-Sec | 32–50 | Dessert. Only this goes with the cake |
Remember the row in the middle of the table, because it breaks the most purchases.Extra Dry is sweeter than Brut, despite the name suggesting the opposite—it's a holdover from the nineteenth century, when the entire region drank considerably sweeter. Whoever once bought Extra Dry expecting a sharp wine, concluded that champagne was not to his liking. It wasn't a problem in champagne.
Another consequence of the same figure: sugar masks. A wine with 10 g/l will swallow a lot of roughness, while Brut Nature has nowhere to hide. That's why Brut Nature is a great cellar test and a bad choice when you don't know what you're buying.
A — someone else's wine dressed in the name of the chain; you don't know what you are buying there and the price is the only information.
Blanc de blancs, blanc de noirs and non-dessert rosé
Blanc de blancsis a wine made from white varieties, in practice almost always one hundred percent Chardonnay, most often from the Côte des Blancs south of Epernay. The chalk in the soil gives it cutting acidity and a narrow, vertical profile—a wine to start dinner, for shrimp, for young goat cheese.Blanc de noirsis from pinot noir and pinot meunier; the body is wider, the apple is baked instead of fresh, and the bottle supports roasted poultry and mushrooms.
Rosé is made here in two ways, and which is which is rarely written, so one has to ask.Rosé d'assemblageit is created by adding a little still red wine to the blend and gives a precise, repeatable result.Rosé de saignéeit is created by a short maceration on the skin, carries more tannins, fruit and color, and can withstand a more serious dish. Neither is a dessert wine: they are as dry as white, and the color is the only difference the guest notices before taking a sip. We explained where that color comes from in the case of still wines, in the text about whycolor and tannins live in the skin.
Vintage, that ismillésime, means that all the grapes are from one year and that the wine has aged the least before shipping36 months. For non-vintage it is the minimum15 monthstotal, of which the least12 on the sediment— and serious cellars routinely double those numbers. The longer sediment gives the smell of brioche and baked yeast that people habitually attribute to oak. There is usually no oak.
Temperature, glass and ice bucket error
Champagne is served on8–10 °C, not at six. An overcooled bottle does not smell of anything, and the bubble becomes aggressive because the gas is more difficult to release from the colder liquid. A good vintage also tolerates 11–12 °C. The pressure in the bottle is approx6 bars, two and a half times more than in your car's tire, which operates at 2.2 to 2.5 bar, which is why the bottle rotates when opened, and the cap holds.
A flute is the wrong vessel for serious champagne — it's too narrow for the aroma to reach the nose. Take a normal sized white wine glass. The same principle applies to calm whites, which we wrote about in the text of Frthe right temperature according to the variety.
Hidden Gems: what the buyer is looking for
It says on the back of an increasing number of bottlesdate of disgorgement(dégorgé le…). It is the moment when the lees are removed and the wine begins to age differently. A bottle disgorged two to three years ago will be rounder than the same bottle disgorged three months ago. If there is a choice, take the older date.
Cote des Barsin the far south of the appellation, closer to Chablis than Reims, it produces Pinot Noir with a sunnier profile and full bottles that sell cheaper simply because they don't have a prestigious address. Today, there is the highest value per dinar.
Coteaux Champenoisis a still wine from the same region, under its own appellation, without bubbles, rare and confusing to the unprepared guest — but it shows the bare structure of the wine from which champagne is made. And finallyréserve perpetuelle: a barrel into which the winegrower pours a new vintage every year, so the bottle carries decades within it. It's in the fine print, and it's one of the rare cases where the fine print is worth more than the name at the top.
Questions & answers
short and to the point- Which champagne to buy for up to 10,000 dinars?
- Look for the RM mark at the bottom of the label, so it's a vineyard champagne, not the entry brut of a big house. Names worth looking for in that range are Pierre Péters, Chartogne-Taillet, Marie-Courtin and Vouette et Sorbée.
- Is Extra Dry drier than Brut?
- No, it's sweeter. Extra Dry has 12–17 g/l of sugar, and Brut up to 12, practically 7–9. The name is a holdover from the nineteenth century and is the most common cause of disappointment when buying.
- At what temperature is champagne served?
- At 8–10 °C, and longer-aged vintage bottles at 11–12 °C. At 6 °C, the wine does not smell of anything, and the bubble becomes sharp.