Beograd · 43°49′NBeograd— Editorial —‹No. 250Ponedeljak / 16·11·202616·11·26
MODUS
Gastronomy · Blog

Carbonara without cream: cheek, pecorino and 65 degrees

Carbonara has five ingredients and one temperature. The sour cream is only there because someone didn't know how to take the pan off the stove.

A plate of spaghetti carbonara with crispy pieces of meat and grated cheese
↳ Photo: Rob Wicks / Unsplash

Sour cream entered carbonara as insurance for cooks who don't know when to take the pan off the heat. The Roman version has none, and no garlic, no mushrooms, no parsley: just pasta, pork cheek, eggs, sheep's cheese and black pepper. Everything that makes the sauce creamy is done by the pasta water and a temperature of about 65 degrees.

in short,what cheese for carbonara:Pecorino Romano, a hard, salty sheep's cheese, alone or half-and-half with Parmesan if pecorino is too sharp for you. For two people: 200 g of pasta, 100 g of guanciale, 3 egg yolks and one whole egg, 40 g of grated pecorino, plenty of freshly ground pepper. No cream.

Guanciale, pancetta or homemade bacon

Guanciale is a cured pork cheek, fattier than bacon and with meat in thin layers. When it is slowly fried, the fat melts into the pan and becomes the basis of the sauce, while the pieces remain crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. In our country, it is found in Italian delicatessens and better butchers' counters, usually in a piece of 200 to 400 g, which is enough for two to four carbonara; in the fridge, wrapped in paper, it keeps for weeks.

MeatTaste in carbonaraJudgment
GuancialeSweet, rich, lots of fatThe original
Pancetta (unsmoked)Milder, less fatGood replacement
Homemade dry bacon, unsmokedClosest to pancettaIt works
Smoked bacon or baconThe smoke overpowers the cheese and eggsSecond, decent pasta, but not carbonara

If you use home-made bacon, choose the pork belly with layers of meat, not the pure back fat. We have described in the text which parts of the board belong whereabout kulen, tea, trout, bacon and prosciutto on one board.

in short, what cheese for carbonara : Pecorino Romano , a hard, salty sheep's cheese, alone or half-and-half with Parmesan if pecorino is too sharp for you.

Eggs that don't curdle: the whole technique

  1. Guancialecut into 1 cm sticks and put in a cold pan, without oil. On medium heat for 8 to 10 minutes, until the fat becomes transparent and the meat is golden.
  2. Pasta(spaghetti, rigatoni or mezze maniche) cook in water with less salt than usual, because both cheese and meat are salty. Take it out of the package a minute ahead of time.
  3. Creamwhisk in a bowl: egg yolk, egg, pecorino and pepper, until it is thick as a paste.
  4. Pastatransfer to a pan with fat, stir, thenremove the pan from the stoveand wait 30 to 60 seconds.
  5. Creampour in, stirring constantly, adding a spoonful of the pasta water, until the sauce is shiny and liquid like thick cream.

Yolks start to coagulate around 65 °C, and whites above 60. The pan directly from the hotplate is over 100 degrees and turns the cream into scrambled eggs in three seconds. Pasta water is full of starch, lowers the temperature and binds the fat with the eggs. If the cast iron pan holds the heat for too long, transfer the pasta to a heated bowl — we explained why iron reacts this way in the textabout the pan which is for what.

Pecorino or Parmesan cheese

Pecorino Romano is sheep cheese, with 5% or more salt and a sharpness that cuts through the fat. Parmesan is cow's, sweeter and nuttier, but it can sound lukewarm in carbonara. The half-and-half mix is ​​a compromise that many Roman kitchens make themselves. It must be grated finely, on the finest grater, otherwise the cheese will form lumps instead of sauce. Our Pirot cheese doesn't help here — it melts into threads, not cream, for the reasons we explained in the textabout cheese that melts and stretches.

Carbonara is not reheated and does not wait. There are two minutes from the moment the cream touches the pasta to the plate; after that, the sauce thickens in the scrambled eggs and no spoonful of water brings it back.

Questions & answers

short and to the point
Which cheese goes in carbonara?
Pecorino Romano, mutton and salt, alone or half-and-half with parmesan. About 40 g, finely grated, is enough for two people.
Does the carbonara go with sour cream?
No. The creamy sauce is made from egg yolks, cheese, guanciale fat and pasta water, with the pan removed from the heat.
Can carbonara with bacon instead of guanciale?
It can be served with unsmoked pancetta or homemade unsmoked bacon. The smoked bacon makes for a delicious pasta, but the smoke overpowers the eggs and cheese.

Read on

from the same press